Sell Tiffany Jewelry

Here’s everything you need to know to Sell Tiffany Jewelry.

We wanted to make the selling process easier for jewelry owners like you, so we created this page, dedicated to helping consumers understand more about how to sell Tiffany jewelry and how to sell it for a good price. If you need information on some helpful tips and tricks that can make it much easier for you to sell Tiffany jewelry, then you can be assured that you will find what you are looking for right here. We’ve included everything from the history of Tiffany to the hows, where’s, and whats of selling jewelry. Happy jewelry selling!


Where is the Best Place to Sell Tiffany Jewelry?

best place to Sell Tiffany Jewelry

New York City is home to many internationally recognized brands, including Tiffany & Company. The jewelry store’s headquarters are based in New York City, on the famous 5th Avenue. This is why many individuals who are looking to sell a Tiffany ring, have no difficulty if they are residents of New York City.

If you’re looking for where to sell Tiffany jewelry in NYC, Manhattan’s very own Diamond District is a great place to start. The Diamond District is also potentially one of the most reliable places to get the best Tiffany jewelry resale value for the piece you are planning to sell. Lining the Diamond District’s streets are thousands of jewelry makers, dealers, and buyers. There, you’ll have no problem selling your Tiffany jewelry for its true worth and value.


Preparing to Sell Tiffany Jewelry

preparing to sell tiffany jewelry

There are two main steps in preparing to sell Tiffany jewelry:
1. Locate its Blue Box and any accompanying documentation. Appraisers and Tiffany jewelry buyers like to see proof of purchase and authentication, so they know the jewelry is the real deal.
2. Clean your jewelry. While unclean jewelry is unlikely to affect your appraisal, it may affect its Tiffany jewelry resale value. Be sure to clean your jewelry piece so it looks exactly as enticing as when it was first purchased.

Also remember: any damage to the jewelry will decrease its value. So, always take good care of Tiffany jewelry. 


Collecting Tiffany & Co.

collecting tiffany and co

For years now, “Tiffany’s” has been synonymous with high-quality and high-style jewelry.

Cherished by New Yorkers and tourists alike, the Tiffany & Co. flagship store on Fifth Avenue, selling Tiffany jewelry, began its walk of fame in 1961 with the movie “Breakfast at Tiffany’s.”

In the film’s famous opening scene, Audrey Hepburn, wearing her character’s iconic black evening gown and chunky pearl collar, stares longingly into the jewel-box windows of Tiffany & Co. As the film continues, the store becomes a sort of refuge for Hepburn’s character: “The quietness and the proud look of it… Nothing very bad could happen to you there.”


Tiffany Beginnings

tiffany beginnings

The company was founded in 1837, when Charles Lewis Tiffany and John P. Young opened a “fancy goods” store on Broadway, adding jewelry and silver to the mix soon after. In 1853, Tiffany took over and the newly-dubbed Tiffany & Co. showcased its exquisite pieces at the Exhibition of the Industry of All Nations in New York, the first World’s Fair held in the U.S. There, Tiffany jewelry was met with rave remarks. “Surpasses anything of the kind ever seen before in this country,” wrote one columnist.

From the beginning, Tiffany & Co. goods embodied three distinct characteristics, according to Tiffany & Co. archivist Annamarie V. Sandecki: “inspiration from either nature or the art of other cultures, innovative technique, and a reliance on unusual gemstones and metals.”


Edward C. Moore

edward c moore

Influenced by his own fascination with foreign culture, Tiffany’s first chief designer, Edward C. Moore, set the design standard for the company, touring silver-making workshops throughout Europe and pulling motifs from Islamic, Hindu, Persian, Japanese, Native American, and Celtic art. Moore left his mark most on tableware designs, such as this hammered silver pitcher with copper leaves, gold vines, and mokume gourds in the “Japonesque” style, c. 1878, which sold for $50,000 at Sotheby’s New York in January 2013. Moore also played a major role in refining the store’s use of enameling on metals, something that has become a distinguished signature of Tiffany jewels.


G. Paulding Farnham

g paulding farnham

Under Moore’s mentorship, George Paulding Furnham became Tiffany’s first celebrity designer. Furnham dedicated his craftsmanship to creating elegant floral designs and enameled orchids. In 1889, Furnham made 24 life-size orchids with pearls, silver, gold, and precious gemstones for the Exposition Universelle in Paris. The collection earned Funham a gold medal and wide jewelry acclaim forever more. 

This enameled yellow orchid brooch, accented with rose-cut diamonds, sold for $173,000 at Sotheby’s New York auction in December 2013.


George Frederick Kunz

george frederick kunz

A defining aspect of Tiffany jewelry by the turn of the 20th century was its unique gemstone selection. Under the direction of chief gemologist George Frederick Kunz, who traveled the world in search of unusual gems, Tiffany moved beyond conventional diamonds, pearls, and carved agate cameos, and began to incorporate Australian opal, aquamarine, and other rare colored stones in their jewelry. They even collected gems mined Stateside, such as oblong pearls from the Mississippi River and Montana sapphires.


Paloma Picasso

paloma picasso

Originally born in France to Pablo Picasso and Françoise Gilot, Paloma Picasso brings bold Italian-style colors to Tiffany’s contemporary collections. Paloma combines shapes and colors such as pink tourmaline, citrine, amethyst, and aquamarine, usually mounted in gold, to create delicate yet powerful designs.

Paloma is a well-known French fashion designer and businesswoman. After meeting career success designing jewelry, Paloma branched out, developing a fragrance line for L'Oréal called Paloma. This encouraged her to later form a cosmetics and bath line including soap, shower gel, and body lotion.


Elsa Peretti

elsa peretti

Since the ‘60s and ‘70s, Tiffany has expanded its reach to more affordable, fashion-forward jewelry. Central among its contemporary designers, Elsa Peretti specializes in sleek, modern forms crafted in sterling silver. Her Bone Cuffs looked just right with a simple, form-fitting Halston frock in the 1970s and continue to look great today.

Elsa originally moved to New York to pursue modeling, but soon switched over to creating jewelry for fashion designers.

By the time Elsa Peretti became an independent designer for Tiffany, she had already received the 1971 Coty Award for American Fashion. The Peretti and Tiffany Co. partnership lasted for over 20 years.


The Tiffany Mark

the tiffany mark

Jewelry produced by Tiffany is fairly easy to identify. Since the U.S. doesn’t have an assay system, Tiffany sends all its jewelry to London to be inspected and stamped by the British assay office. Tiffany & Co. is one of the only U.S.-based jewelry houses that produces hallmarked pieces.

Another iconic trademark of Tiffany is the Tiffany Blue Box that comes with every Tiffany jewelry purchase. The particular hue of blue used for these boxes has become so associated with the company, it has since been dubbed the name ‘Tiffany Blue.’

All authentic Tiffany jewelry comes in a Tiffany Blue Box.


Sell Tiffany Jewelry

Sell Tiffany Jewelry

Today, Tiffany sends their jewelry to London to be hallmarked, or trademarked. The name "Tiffany" is etched onto every piece of jewelry to mark its authenticity. When selling Tiffany jewelry, be sure your piece has the brand visibly etched on, because that is the first thing Tiffany jewelry buyers look for.

Fortunately, thanks to the name itself carrying a significant amount of prestige, it is not particularly difficult to resell Tiffany jewelry. So, you can be confident that the Tiffany jewelry resale value will always be high on any pieces that you may have. Jewelry collectors are always looking to buy real Tiffany pieces for competitive prices. So, before making the final sale, be confident you are getting the best deal possible for selling Tiffany jewelry. Look for reputable jewelry buyers like Luriya, where we use precisely calibrated scales and tools.


The “Blue Book”

tiffany blue book

In 1845, Tiffany & Co. released its first mail-order catalog called the “Blue Book.” The catalog made it possible to sell Tiffany jewelry to NYC and across the United States. Still published today, the Blue Book not only features luxury jewelry but also some of the most beautiful and rarest jewels. Jewelry connoisseurs from around the world anticipate this one-of-a-kind catalog, hopeful to get their hands on some of Tiffany’s treasures early.

Today, you can access the Blue Book online (and make a Tiffany and Co. online sale) as well as get one in the mail. Consider taking a look at this year’s catalog – maybe you’ll be inspired.


Vintage Tiffany Jewelry

vintage tiffany jewelry

Tiffany jewelry resale can be a great option if you’re not sure what to do with old Tiffany jewelry or what to do with unwanted tiffany jewelry.

Tiffany jewelry resale value regularly ranks at competitive pricing. Tiffany & Co. pieces are timeless, particularly the more traditional lines, and therefore make Tiffany jewelry resale a breeze.

If you are trying to sell a Tiffany necklace, ring, or other Tiffany piece, it’s recommended to start with a free appraisal. This way, you know the worth of your jewelry before you go to sell.


Selling Tiffany Engagement Rings

selling tiffany engagement rings

If you’re looking to sell Tiffany engagement ring, but do not have its original Tiffany Blue Box and paperwork, you can contact Tiffany & Co. to get your paperwork, as long as you were the original purchaser. Getting proof of purchase documentation is invaluable to getting your appraisal.

Once you’ve gotten an appraisal, you can sell Tiffany jewelry online or to a private jewelry buyer like Luriya, with confidence. Keep in mind that for most individuals who are trying to sell a Tiffany ring, the best value will often come from private buyers or jewelry collectors.

It is important to note that Tiffany will not repurchase any items they have sold, so it is not possible to simply return the ring.


Tiffany Special Honors

tiffany special honors

While it’s common knowledge that Tiffany & Co. makes many trophies, such as the Super Bowl’s Vince Lombardi trophy and the NBA Finals Larry O’Brien Trophy, not everyone knows that the company also designed a medal for the Navy. The “Tiffany Cross” as it became known as, was an incredibly rare medal. Initially, it was awarded for combat heroism, but then in 1942, it was changed to non-combat heroism. Later that year, unfortunately, it was eliminated. Tiffany & Co. has also designed for the Russian Royal Family and the White House on many occasions.

Have a jewelry expert appraise your fine items

Send in your valuables to get the best price